SEO Agency vs. In-House Experts – What’s Right for You?

SEO Agency vs. In-House Experts

When it comes to improving your website’s search engine rankings, you’re faced with a big decision. Should you hire an SEO agency or build an in-house team? Both options come with unique advantages and drawbacks, and the best choice depends on your business’s goals, resources, and budget.

If you’re a small business owner or a marketing manager trying to decide what works best for your organization, this guide will walk you through the pros and cons of each choice. By the end, you’ll have a clearer understanding of what’s right for your business.

SEO Agency vs. In-House

What Does SEO Support Entail?

Before comparing options, it’s helpful to understand what SEO support involves.

Effective SEO (Search Engine Optimization) includes tasks such as:

  • Conducting keyword research
  • Optimizing website content and structure
  • Building quality backlinks
  • Performing technical SEO audits
  • Tracking and analyzing website performance
  • Staying up-to-date with search engine algorithm changes

Both agencies and in-house experts can excel at these tasks—but the right choice hinges on how you prioritize expertise, cost, and scalability.

Benefits of Hiring an SEO Agency

Hiring an SEO agency can be particularly appealing for small businesses and marketing teams looking for specialized knowledge and scalability. Here’s why:

  1. Access to a Team of Experts

Agencies typically house a team of SEO specialists with diverse skill sets. You’re not just getting one person – you’re gaining access to professionals who specialize in technical SEO, content optimization, link building, and more.

Example: If your website has technical issues like slow loading times or broken links, an SEO agency can quickly resolve these problems by leveraging the expertise of its technical SEOs.

  1. Tailored Strategies and Fresh Perspectives

SEO agencies bring fresh perspectives to your strategy. Because they work with clients across industries, they often have innovative approaches and insights that your in-house team might not think of. They’ll tailor SEO strategies based on your specific needs.

  1. Scalability and Flexibility

Need to scale up for a holiday campaign or slow things down during the off-season? Most agencies can adjust to meet your needs. With contracts often structured for flexibility, you can increase or decrease your engagement based on your business demands.

  1. Access to Advanced Tools

Agencies often have access to high-priced SEO tools like SEMrush, Ahrefs, or Moz. These tools are essential for delivering in-depth insights and streamlining SEO processes—and hiring an agency gives you access to these resources without the steep cost of purchasing them.

  1. Cost-Effectiveness

For some businesses, outsourcing SEO is more cost-effective than building an in-house team. You’re not paying salaries, benefits, or training costs—just one flat fee to the agency.

Key Consideration

While agencies bring valuable expertise, communication can sometimes be a challenge. It’s essential to find an agency that prioritizes collaboration and stays aligned with your goals.

Challenges of Working with an SEO Agency

While SEO agencies offer many benefits, they aren’t without drawbacks. Some potential issues include:

  • Lack of Industry-Specific Knowledge: Agencies may not be deeply familiar with the nuances of your industry, resulting in strategies that don’t fully address your audience’s needs.
  • Cost: High-quality agencies can be expensive, making it a less viable option for businesses with tighter budgets.
  • Communication Barriers: When outsourcing, you might encounter delays in project updates or decision-making depending on the agency’s communication practices.

Benefits of Building an In-House SEO Team

The second option is building an in-house team of SEO experts to work exclusively on your business. Although this route requires more upfront investment, it offers unique advantages.

  1. Full Control Over Your Strategy

With an in-house team, you have complete control over your SEO efforts. Your team is solely focused on your business, giving you the ability to pivot strategies quickly based on internal priorities or market changes.

Example: If your competitor launches a new product and you want to create a dedicated SEO campaign in response, an in-house team can implement the changes immediately without lengthy approval processes.

  1. Team Alignment with Business Goals

An in-house team is more deeply connected to your company culture and goals. They understand the brand voice, target audience, and history better than any external agency could.

  1. Availability for Real-Time Collaboration

Unlike outsourced agencies, in-house teams are available during your business hours for real-time collaboration. This ensures faster execution without the delays that can occur when working with an external partner.

  1. Industry Expertise

Your in-house team becomes specialists in your niche over time. They gain a deep understanding of your industry and can create highly customized strategies that appeal to your unique audience.

  1. Long-Term Investment

Though building an in-house team requires upfront costs, the long-term benefits can justify the investment. You’ll have a dedicated resource focused on growing and refining your online presence over time.

Key Consideration

The challenge with in-house teams is finding and retaining talent. The hiring process can be lengthy, and training can take months. Additionally, some businesses struggle to keep up with the costs associated with salaries, benefits, and tools.

Challenges of Building an In-House Team

While enticing, building an in-house team has its own hurdles:

  • Higher Costs: Salaries, benefits, and tools can add up quickly and may exceed your budget, especially for small businesses.
  • Time-Intensive Hiring: The recruitment process for skilled SEO professionals can be time-consuming and competitive.
  • Dependency on Talent: Retaining SEO talent may be a challenge, especially as professionals often seek growth opportunities or higher pay in the fast-moving marketing industry.

Choosing What’s Right for You

Still unsure which option makes the most sense for your business? Here are a few scenarios to help you decide:

  • Choose an SEO Agency if…
      • You want access to a diverse team of experts.
      • You need scalable and flexible solutions.
      • You prefer a cost-effective alternative to building a team from scratch.
      • Your team lacks in-house SEO expertise.
  • Build an In-House Team if…
      • You want full control over your SEO strategy.
      • You value having a team deeply aligned with your business goals.
      • You’re willing to invest in long-term growth.
      • Your business operates in a niche industry, requiring specialization.

How Both Can Work Together

You don’t always have to choose one or the other. Many businesses adopt a hybrid approach. For example:

  • An in-house team may handle daily SEO tasks, like content creation and minor optimizations.
  • Meanwhile, an agency may oversee larger, more complex projects like technical audits and link-building campaigns.

This combo can deliver the best of both worlds.

Empower Your Decision Today

Your decision between an SEO agency and an in-house team will shape your website’s online success. Assess your business priorities, budget, and goals carefully before making a move.

Need more clarity on where to start? Partnering with an SEO consultant or scheduling an audit can provide you with deeper insights into your needs. Whichever option you choose, prioritizing SEO is no longer optional if you want to stay competitive in today’s landscape.

Discover how SEO can help you generate more leads!
Schedule 15 min call.